Hamilton Meets High School Chapter 21

Enjoy the last happy chapter before We Know happens. New Year’s, yay! Here are chapters 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 BONUS 18 19 20 !!!


“Five minutes until 2019!” John exclaims. “Everyone have their new year’s resolution?” They’re all at Times Square to watch the ball drop.

“Sure do,” Herc replies.

“Yep,” Alex says.

“Still thinking,” Laff answers.

“Dude, you’ve been thinking for the last hour, and you still have nothing,” Hercules points out.

“I know, I know. You know how bad I am at these. Hm… Hey, I got it now!” he exclaims.

“That’s the fifth time you’ve said that,” Alex says.

“Well this time I really got one.”

“Good,” John says. “Can you guys believe all four of us have only been friends for a little over two years?”

“I feel like I’ve known you guys my whole life,” Alex remarks.

“Exactly!” John says, throwing his hands in the air. “And isn’t it crazy that we’re actually here in Time Square?”

“We’ve done this two or three years in a row,” Laff points out.

“I know, I know. But it’s still really cool! We actually get to see the ball drop! Oh, and what if we get on TV?” John asks excitedly.

“John, chill,” Alex says with a laugh.

It’s time for the countdown. “Ten! Nine! Eight! Seven! Six! Five! Four! Three! Two! One! HAPPY NEW YEAR!!!” everyone in the crowd shouts.

Hercules pulls Lafayette into a kiss, and John whoops. “Alright alright!” he shouts.

“This is going to be a great year!” Alexander exclaims.

Will it, Alex? Will it?

Mr. Mulligan says, “Alright boys, we better head back. We’ve got a half hour drive ahead of us, plus traffic which will make it over an hour long.”

They make their way through the crowd, and after twenty minutes, finally get to the car and climb in. They rented a bigger car for the night so that they can all fit without anyone getting squished. There are two seats next to eat other in the middle, leaving an open space on the left for people to climb into to get to the seats in the back. Laff and Herc sit in the middle, and John and Alex climb into the back.

Not ten minutes later, Herc is already asleep on Laff’s shoulder, and Lafayette is resting his head on top of his boyfriend’s.

“They’re so cute together,” John whispers. Alex nods and takes out his phone, taking a picture of the two of them.

John yawns and leans his head against the seat. “G’night,” he murmurs, closing his eyes.

“Good night John. Happy new year.”

Alex stays awake, watching people go by and willing the cars in front of them to go faster.

After a few minutes, he feels a weight on his shoulder and sees that John’s head is on his shoulder. He smiles slightly and adjusts himself to make it more comfortable for John. Alex watches him peacefully sleep, his beautiful eyes closed and his freckles more apparent than ever. And in that moment, he realizes how perfect and innocent he is, and he vows to protect him. He ends up falling asleep, his head resting on John’s.

John is the first to wake up, and it’s when they still have about ten more minutes until they get home. He then realises his position. He’s about to move when he realises it would wake up Alex. Besides, sleep is trying to pull him under. So he just snuggles closer to Alex and falls back asleep.

Herc and Laff wake up at the same time when they get to Herc’s house. Lafayette nudges Hercules and points to their other friends.

“I’m going to take a picture,” he whispers quietly. He pulls out his phone and takes a picture of the two of them peacefully sleeping.

Herc then nudges Alexander’s leg and says gently, “Hey, Alex, time to get up.” He stirs and opens one eye. He yawns and nudges John.

“John. Hey, John. Time to get up.” John groans and opens his eyes. He then stretches and sits up.

They all unbuckle and head inside. They all grab their pajamas and change before heading toward the pile of blankets and pillows where they will be sleeping. John hardly pulls the blankets over himself before he’s asleep.

Laff nudges Alex and whispers, “Look at you two.” He shows him the picture of the two of them sleeping in the backseat.

Instead of getting mad, he smiles and replies, “Can you send that to me?”

“Sure thing.”

Alex climbs under the blankets, and he falls asleep within minutes.


It’s ten o’clock when John wakes up. Still drowsy, he opens one eye to see Alex watching him silently. Then he notices that they’re only a few inches apart. He must have turned over in his sleep and somehow moved closer to him.

“Well good morning,” John groans, his eyelids feeling heavy.

“Morning sunshine,” Alex replies.

John squints and murmurs, “Did you just call me sunshine?”

“Maybe I did, maybe I didn’t,” Alex replies.

John bites his lip and begins to blush. He rolls over so that Alex doesn’t see, but he just finds Laff laying on his back, looking at the ceiling. He glances at John and, seeing his blush, raises his eyebrows. John decides that he’ll just put his head in the pillow.

About five minutes later, Laff nudges him and asks, “You want donuts for breakfast?”

John turns his head so that one eye is looking at Laff. “Of course I do,” he states.

Lafayette sits up and nudges Herc. “Come on Herc, we’re going to get donuts at the Krispy Kreme nearby.”

Hercules groans and asks, “Why me?”

“Because this is your house, and I don’t want to go alone,” Laff answers.

“Fine.” They get up and leave within ten minutes.

John just lays there, his face still in the pillow, not wanting to get up.

“John,” Alex whispers.

“What?” John replies, lifting his head up slightly.

“Can I tell you something?”

John adjusts himself so that he’s looking at Alex. “What is it?”

Lafayette comes back and asks, “I forgot, what kinds do you guys want?”

“Just get a dozen assorted,” John replies. Laff nods and leaves. John looks back at Alex and asks, “So?”

He opens his mouth to say something, but then shuts it again. “Never mind,” he says, not meeting his friend’s eyes.

Marie-Joseph Paul Yves Roch Gilbert de Motier Lafayette you are in so much trouble when you get back, John thinks. “No, it’s alright. Tell me,” he encourages.

“Just… never mind. It’s nothing,” Alex says, turning away.

“Alright, if you say so.”

They come back in about twenty minutes with the donuts. John is still laying down, and Alex is flipping through channels on the TV. John would say something to Laff, but he has doughnuts. And he wants doughnuts.

“We got donuts!” Laff announces.

John sits bolt upright and stands up quickly. Too quick. His vision goes blurry and he gets dizzy, which is what happens when you stand up too fast. It’s honestly the worst.

Alex puts a hand on his shoulder and asks, “Are you alright?”

“Yeah, yeah, just stood up too fast. Now let’s eat donuts!”

Once they’re done eating, they all go to John’s house to help Alex pack. It’s time for him to stay at Herc’s house, where he will stay until April.

“Mon ami, you’ve had a week to pack. Why is nothing packed yet?” Lafayette scolds, going into Momayette mode.

“I wanted to hang out, not pack!” Alex explains, shoving clothes into his suitcase, covering his special box.

“Well now you have to pack, so ha!” Laff retorts.

“At least you guys are helping me,” Alex shoots back.

After fifteen more minutes, they’re done, and they help Alex bring the stuff over to Herc’s house. He then spends the rest of the day unpacking.


School has come back. Despite not wanting it to, it came back. And on the first day back, Mr. Washington gives them an assignment.

“I am going to put you into groups, and each group will have to present their projects using a slideshow. The requirements and topic options are on the piece of paper you got when you walked into class.”

Alex thinks Please don’t put me with Jefferson, please don’t put me with Jefferson, PLEASE DON’T PUT ME WITH JEFFERSON!

“I will call out three random names, and those people will be your partners. The first group: Hercules Mulligan, Eliza Schuyler,  and Maria Reynolds.”

Okay, decent people, Herc thinks. I just hope Eliza and Maria don’t argue.

“John Laurens, Peggy Schuyler, Charles Lee, and Jasmine Jones.”

NOT CHARLES!!! At least Peggy is nice, And Jasmine… waIT JASMINE! John thinks. Oh no. Oh nonononononono. Jasmine? Frick. Frcikfrickfrickfrick.

“Lafayette, Aaron Burr, and Thomas Jefferson.”

NNNNNOOOOOO!!!!! Lafayette thinks, not wanting to be with either of these people. Alex feels bad for him, but it would be more disastrous if he got Jefferson.

“Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and John Jay.”

Ew, Jefferson’s little friend. And who the heck is John Jay? Alex thinks. Mr. Washington calls out a few more groups, and then they get into their groups.

Alex joins up with James Madison and a short boy with ash blonde hair and grey eyes, which he assumes is John Jay. “So, what do you guys want to do?” Alexander asks, breaking the silence.

“Um, maybe the Constitution and the Federalist Papers?” Jay suggests.

“I like that idea,” Madison remarks.

“Me too. Okay, so maybe we can do twenty five different slides, divided evenly among us?” Hamilton suggests.

“Sure,” Jay says.

“Alright,” Madison agrees.

While Alex is dealing with a pretty chill group, Lafayette is suffering under the wrath of Jefferson and Burr. But it’s a very… interesting argument.

“Believe me, I look way better than you,” Jefferson insists.

“Guys, you look exactly the same!” Burr argues.

“Well, I can pull off a bun better than you,” Lafayette replies, ignoring Aaron.

“Yeah right!” Thomas laughs.

“Guys, you look exactly the same. You want proof? Look at the Holly incident!” he exclaims. Laff shuts up right away, not wanting to go down that road.

“Let’s just do the assignment,” he says.

They get to work, snide remarks thrown here and there.

Hercules is trying his best to get Eliza and Maria to talk to one another. “Gals, you got into a fight four or five months ago! Just put it past you!”

“No,” Maria says. “Besides, there is another reason I hate her.” She thinks back to when she started dating Alexander, and she had a crush on him. But little does Eliza know, she got her revenge. And she will probably never know.

“And what might that be?” Eliza challenges.

“Girls! Work!” Hercules shouts. They send glares at one another, but finally get to work.

John is about to burst. “I freaking swear Lee if you say one more thing like that to Peggy, you’ll be looking at her through a black eye and three missing teeth,” he threatens.

“I can flirt with her if I want, Laurens! You can’t stop me,” Charles says defiantly, crossing his arms.

“Charles, stop,” Peggy cuts in. “I’m not interested.”

He winks and replies, “Not yet at least. But I can flirt with Jasmine.” He winks at her. She’s a cute girl with short brown hair and grey-blue eyes. She has a few scattered freckles across her nose and cheeks, and she’s the kind of girl that never wears makeup. She is wearing black turtleneck with a grey scarf, jeans, and boots.

“Don’t you dare!” John growls, his voice rising, and his face beginning to turn pink. From anger or embarrassment, it’s hard to tell.

“Yeah, I have a boyfriend,” she says in her soft voice.

“Oh come on, can’t I have one of your two lovely ladies? I can guarantee that I’m the best kisser at this school,” he says, trying to be seductive.

Peggy has to hold John back so that Lee isn’t beaten to a pulp. Charles laughs.

“Oh, does your girlfriend have to hold you back?” he taunts.

That’s how Peggy ends up in the principal’s office, not a scratch on her. But… the same can’t be said for Lee. He has a black eyes, a bleeding lip, a cut on his cheek, and his nose is bleeding, possible broken again.

“Young lady, what made you do this?” Principal Frederick asks, his hands crossed in front of him.

“He provoked me. The jerk got what he deserved,” she says definitely, not caring if she gets suspended.

He sighs. “Witnesses can confirm you were provoked. But that still doesn’t excuse your behavior. You are suspended from school for two days, starting tomorrow. You can go the rest of the day, however. You are dismissed.”

When she walks out of the principal’s office, John is waiting for her. “Hey, you really didn’t have to do that, Peggy,” he says, following her down the hall.

“Yeah, I kind of did. You’re right, he’s a total jerk.”

“Now he’s gotten beaten up two times. Once by me, which I think embarrassed him a little bit. Now by you, and I doubt he’ll ever wanna show his face again because not only was he beaten up by a girl, but you didn’t get injured at all! I bet you he’ll say ‘I didn’t want to hit a girl’.”

She laughs. “He probably will. And, thanks, John.”

He glances sideways at her, confused. “For what?”

“For not trying to stop me.” They both laugh and head to their next classes.

Alex has been typing furiously on his computer, working on his history project. He’s already gone past the eight he needed to do, and it appears Madison has done the same, too. Jay has only worked on two of them.

“Alex, you need to take a break,” Herc says, leaning in his doorframe.

“But there’s so much to say!” Alex argues, still typing.

Herc sighs, and says, “Fine. At least it gives you something to do while we shop for your birthday presents.”

“Mhmm,” Alex replies, only half listening. Herc sighs and leaves.

Alexander’s birthday is on January 11th, which is on Friday. Today is Monday, and his friends are going shopping for gifts.

Alex just types away while his friends search high and low for the perfect gifts that he didn’t get at Christmas. And let’s just say, it’s hard. But they manage.

The next day at school, Madison comes up to Alex and asks, “How the heck did you type so much last night?”

He shrugs. “I type fast. And I found there was a lot to say.” James shakes his head slowly and walks away to join Jefferson.

It’s Thursday, and Alex can’t wait until his birthday. He’ll finally be fifteen years old! It seems like a magical number for some reason.

Today, they have to present their slideshows. And if I said Mr. Washington was amazed with the number of slides (85; 5 were Jay, 29 were Madison, and Hamilton wrote the other 51), that would be an understatement. The whole class was beyond amazement, and they were certain to get an A+. Alex walked back to his seat, satisfied and full of pride.

Herc, John, and Laff were able to manage with their groups, but nobody did as good as Alexander’s group. And during this project, Lafayette has maybe or maybe not kind of become friends with Jefferson, but that’s just when he’s alone with him. When Laff is with his friends, Thomas goes back to being a jerk. But otherwise, they’re on okay terms.

During lunch, Eliza comes over to his table and asks, “Um, John, could I maybe see you for a moment?”

Confused, John gets up and follows her a ways away. “Okay, I need your opinion on something,” she says quietly.

“My opinion? Really? Hm, what is it?” John asks.

She glances at Alexander and makes sure he is not looking before whispering, “For Alex’s birthday, I made him a ‘365 Reasons Why I Love You’ book. Do you think he’ll like it?”

John smiles. “Yeah, he’ll love that,” he says quietly.

“Thanks John! I owe you one!” She then skips off to her friends.

John walks back and is immediately pestered with questions.

“Alright, what did she want?” Alex asks skeptically.

“Nothing…” John replies guiltily.

“Tell meeeee,” he pleads.

“I’ll tell you… in thirty six hours.”

“Oh whatever,” he replies, pouting.

Later that day, it’s 11:58, and Hercules is letting Laff and John into the house. Hopefully, they are able to scare Alex.

When it hits midnight, John literally jumps on top of Alex and shouts at the top of his lungs, along with the other two, “HAPPY BIRTHDAY!!!”

He bolts awake, his heart pounding and his eyes wide open. He shouts, “YOU GUYS!” He shoves John playfully and complains, “I was having the best dream?”

“And who was it about?” Laff asks, his eyebrows raised.

Alexander’s face turns a red deeper than Maria’s lipstick, which is really saying something. “No one!” he replies, his voice going up two octaves.

“Mhmm…” Herc says without much conviction. “Just keep telling yourself that.”

“Present time!” John exclaims, emptying the bag of presents onto the edge of his bed.

Alex eyes them before picking a green and silver gift. He rips off the paper to find a Slytherin hoodie. It is a well known fact that he is a Slytherin, and he’s proud of it, too.

He gasps and pulls it out. “OH MY GOSH!” he exclaims. He feels sorry for Herc’s parents, who are probably trying to sleep. He slips it on and adds, “It’s a perfect fit!”

“I knew you’d love it!” John says.

“Thank you guys!” He continues opening presents, and he’s satisfied with everything he got. “Oh, there’s one more thing I need to see. John, come here.” He stands right in front of John and brings his hand from the top of his head to just above John’s. “I’m taller now!”

“What? No, you’re not! Herc, get a book,” John says, not wanting it to be true. They stand back to back, and find that the book is slanted, showing that Alexander is taller.

“I’m finally taller than you!” Alex shouts in triumph. “Finally! Now you’re the shortest of the group!”

“Well, I might grow taller!” John argues.

“Probably not,” Laff says. “But hey, at least it’s not like you’re 5’ 4” or anything like that.”

“True…” John says.

Alex says his thank you for the hundredth time before Laff and John head home. He falls asleep, already at a good start of his birthday.

He wakes up to someone knocking on his bedroom door. He sits up and says, “Come in.” Hercules opens the door to reveal James. Alexander’s face spreads into a huge smile, and he runs up to his brother, giving him a big hug.

“James!” he exclaims.

“Hey Alex. Happy fifteenth birthday! I got you something.” He holds out a beautifully wrapped gift.

Alex takes it and opens it to find papers bound by string. He opens it to find page upon page of “Time With Your Brother” coupons. There are things like “Go to Starbucks”, “Have dinner”, and other things like that.

“Since I haven’t seen you in so long, I thought this would be a great way to catch up,” James explains.

Alexander hugs him again and says, “I love it! Thank you so, so much!”

James chuckles softly. “Now you better get ready for school, and I gotta go. I’ll call you night, alright?”

“Alright!” he replies. James then leaves.

Alex gets ready, slipping on his new hoodie. He eats breakfast and has a cup of coffee before heading to school.

During lunch, Eliza comes up to him and exclaims, “Happy birthday! I got you something.” She hands him a small silver present that’s about six inches by four inches and two inches high. Curious, he opens it to find a leather bound group of papers, with the title ‘365 Reasons Why I Love You’ on the cover.

“Oh my gosh, Eliza, did you make this?” Alex asks with awe, opening it up to a random page.

“I did,” she replies, trying to hide her pride.

He stands up and gives her a short kiss before saying, “Thank you so much! I love it!”

She smiles. “I knew you would.”

That night, they have the best New York pizza for dinner and birthday cake. Overall, it has been a wonderful birthday, and a wonderful new year (even though it’s only been eleven days). Life is perfect.

If only it could stay that way.

About the author: THE-Fangirl

I am part of the following fandoms:
Harry Potter, Hamilton (An American Musical), Dear Evan Hansen, Be More Chill, Newsies, In The Heights, Lorien Legacies, The Gone Novels, Maze Runner, Hunger Games, Delerium, Uglies, and more.
I love to write on my spare time, and I'd like to give a shout out to KatherineElizaEponineHamilton for being the first person to read my work. Thank you!

Let's fan about it!

Share, read, grow your fans and fan out!

Social blog hosting for young women.


No comments yet